Kenya’s Secondhand Clothing Sector Fights Back Against Misinformation and Punitive Policies
The Mitumba Consortium Association of Kenya (MCAK), a leading voice for the secondhand clothing industry, is challenging the narrative that paints their trade as a primary contributor to textile waste. Representing over two million traders and impacting 6.2 million households who regularly purchase secondhand clothing, MCAK asserts that over 95% of imported secondhand clothes are not waste, contrary to widely circulated misinformation. The association has embarked on a global advocacy campaign, urging policymakers to base decisions on robust data and research rather than inaccurate claims propagated by fast fashion interests. They argue that punitive taxes and regulations threaten the livelihood of millions dependent on this sustainable practice and undermine a vital component of the circular economy.
MCAK Chairperson Teresia Wairimu Njenga has spearheaded this campaign, travelling extensively in 2024 to engage with stakeholders across the EU, UK, Ghana, and the US. These meetings consistently revealed the shared challenges faced by textile collectors, sorters, upcyclers, and recyclers, who are grappling with increasing costs and regulations. Njenga emphasizes that these burdens threaten the financial viability and competitiveness of the secondhand clothing trade, especially against the backdrop of the burgeoning fast fashion industry. The EU’s emerging policies on textile supply chains are of particular concern, as they are likely to set a global precedent and significantly impact livelihoods in developing countries like Kenya.
The association highlights the damaging impact of misinformation, particularly the often-cited yet flawed statistic claiming that 40% of imported secondhand clothing is waste. MCAK points to multiple academic studies conducted in Ghana, Kenya, and Uganda, which they have supported and endorsed, demonstrating that less than 5% of these imports are actually waste. This misinformation, they argue, unfairly blames secondhand clothing imports for broader waste management failures and diverts attention from the real culprit: the overproduction of fast fashion. MCAK urges policymakers to focus on addressing systemic waste management issues and the unsustainable practices of the fast fashion industry, rather than penalizing a sector that actively contributes to a circular economy.
The MCAK’s advocacy efforts center on promoting the vital role of secondhand clothing in reducing textile waste and supporting sustainable consumption. They emphasize that reuse, collection, sorting, upcycling, and recycling are integral components of a circular economy, and policymakers should prioritize supporting these practices. With the EU’s mandatory textile collection slated to begin in 2025, MCAK urges policymakers to target new clothing producers, holding them accountable for their environmental impact, rather than hindering the operations of circular economy actors like those in the secondhand clothing trade.
Njenga warns against the “demonization” of the secondhand clothing trade, cautioning that allowing this narrative to persist serves the interests of fast fashion, which benefits from the suppression of its sustainable competitor. She argues that by misrepresenting secondhand clothing as the problem, policymakers risk exacerbating global textile pollution. Instead, they should recognize the industry as a vital solution to the overproduction crisis, offering affordable and sustainable clothing options while supporting livelihoods in developing nations.
The MCAK calls for a shift in focus, urging policymakers to support existing circular economy models within the secondhand clothing industry and to implement policies that address the root cause of textile waste: the overproduction of fast fashion. They advocate for a data-driven approach, emphasizing the need to base policy decisions on accurate research and evidence, rather than misleading narratives that serve vested interests. The future of the secondhand clothing industry, and the livelihoods of millions dependent on it, hinges on this critical reassessment of its role in the global textile landscape. The MCAK’s ongoing advocacy efforts are crucial to ensuring that the narrative shifts towards recognizing the true value and sustainability of the secondhand clothing trade.