Spanish Newspaper La Vanguardia and The Guardian Abandon X (Formerly Twitter) Citing Toxicity and Misinformation
Barcelona-based newspaper La Vanguardia and British news outlet The Guardian have announced their withdrawal from Elon Musk’s social media platform X, formerly known as Twitter, citing concerns over its increasingly toxic environment and the proliferation of misinformation. Both publications expressed deep unease about the platform’s trajectory under Musk’s ownership, highlighting the spread of hate speech, conspiracy theories, and the erosion of effective content moderation.
La Vanguardia articulated its decision in a strongly worded statement, condemning X’s transformation into an "echo chamber" for harmful content. The newspaper specifically cited "hatred of ethnic minorities, misogyny and racism" among the viral posts that violate human rights while simultaneously attracting user engagement and advertising revenue. The decision to leave, the paper stated, was solidified by the purported appointment of Musk and Vivek Ramaswamy to head a "Department of Government Efficiency" by US President-elect Donald Trump, a claim that appears unsubstantiated and possibly related to the circulation of misinformation on the platform itself. The growing presence of bots amplifying toxic narratives, particularly during the recent devastating floods in Spain, further solidified the newspaper’s decision.
The Guardian echoed these concerns, stating that X had become a "toxic media platform" where Musk’s influence has demonstrably shaped political discourse. The newspaper emphasized that the platform’s negative aspects now outweigh any potential benefits, leading them to redirect their resources towards promoting journalism elsewhere. While acknowledging they had been considering this move for some time, The Guardian stated that the recent US election "underlined" the urgency of their decision.
Both publications highlighted Musk’s self-proclaimed "free speech absolutism" and the subsequent gutting of content moderation teams as key factors contributing to the platform’s decline. Since acquiring Twitter in a $44 billion deal in 2022, Musk has overseen mass layoffs, including staff responsible for combating misinformation and harmful content. He has also reinstated accounts of known conspiracy theorists, sparking widespread criticism.
La Vanguardia, while ceasing publication on X, clarified that it would continue monitoring the platform to stay informed about public conversations and debates relevant to its readership. The newspaper’s journalists will also retain the option to use X individually, provided they adhere to the organization’s guidelines on restraint, respect for human rights, and freedom of expression.
These departures represent a significant development in the ongoing debate surrounding online content moderation and the responsibility of social media platforms in combating misinformation. The decisions by La Vanguardia and The Guardian underscore the growing unease among reputable news organizations with the direction of X under Musk’s leadership and raise questions about the platform’s long-term viability as a space for credible information sharing. The timing of these announcements, in the wake of a contentious US election, further emphasizes the critical role of social media in shaping public discourse and the potential consequences of unchecked misinformation.
The exodus of established news organizations from X may signal a broader trend of reputable sources seeking alternative platforms that prioritize accuracy and responsible content moderation. It also raises questions about the future of X and whether its current trajectory will lead to further polarization and the erosion of trust in online information. As more organizations reassess their relationship with X, the platform faces increasing pressure to address the growing concerns about its role in amplifying harmful content. The long-term impact of these departures on both X and the broader online information ecosystem remains to be seen.