Oscar-Nominated Actress Karla Sofía Gascón Deactivates X Account Amidst Controversy Over Past Tweets
Karla Sofía Gascón, the first openly transgender performer nominated for an acting Oscar, has deactivated her X account following a storm of criticism over resurfaced tweets. The tweets, which date back several years, contain inflammatory remarks on various sensitive topics, including the 2020 murder of George Floyd, Muslim immigration in Spain, and religions perceived as conflicting with European values. The controversy erupted just 24 hours prior to Gascón’s statement to The Hollywood Reporter, throwing her Oscar campaign into turmoil. Gascón, who won the best actress award at Cannes for her portrayal of a transgender cartel leader in Emilia Pérez, had positioned her campaign as a symbol of progress against rising anti-trans sentiment.
Gascón’s statement to The Hollywood Reporter, sent “between tears,” explains her decision to leave the platform. She cites relentless online harassment, including death threats and abuse, and expresses a need to protect her daughter. Gascón acknowledges the “erroneous” nature of her past opinions, attributing them partly to the toxic environment of social media. While apologizing for any offense caused, she also hints at a potential orchestrated campaign to sabotage her Oscar chances, suggesting a “very dark” motive behind the unearthed tweets.
The actress, who has been a prolific social media user, describes her past tweets as personal reflections and notes, intended for creative purposes rather than public scrutiny. She defends her history of supporting minority groups and speaking out against racism and homophobia, while also acknowledging her own self-criticism. Gascón maintains that her intent was never to endorse war, injustice, extremism, or oppression. She emphasizes her fallibility and willingness to learn from mistakes, distinguishing between her own words and the interpretations others impose upon them.
Gascón expresses hope for a future opportunity to offer a more comprehensive explanation of her views. She pleads for understanding, acknowledging the difficulty of addressing every accusation leveled against her. Despite the onslaught of criticism, Gascón declares that the attacks only strengthen her resolve, and that the eventual "victory" will be even greater. The statement concludes with a reiteration of her apology and the phrase "NAM MYOHO RENGE KYO," a mantra from Nichiren Buddhism, which Gascón identifies as her spiritual practice for over a decade.
The controversy surrounding Gascón’s tweets has sparked a complex debate. While some condemn her past statements as unequivocally offensive, others argue for a more nuanced understanding, considering the context of social media and the potential for evolving perspectives. The incident raises questions about the role of social media in public life, the scrutiny faced by public figures, and the complexities of navigating past statements in the present. It also highlights the challenges faced by transgender individuals in the public eye, particularly amidst a backdrop of increasing polarization and societal debates regarding identity.
The Academy now faces a difficult decision. Gascón’s nomination, initially celebrated as a landmark moment for transgender representation, is now overshadowed by controversy. The Academy must weigh the gravity of her past statements against her artistic achievements and the broader context of her career. The outcome of Gascón’s Oscar campaign remains uncertain, but the controversy has undoubtedly left a mark on the 2025 awards season, raising important questions about accountability, redemption, and the evolving nature of public discourse. The incident serves as a stark reminder of the power and peril of social media, and the long-lasting impact of online expressions, particularly in the age of instantaneous information dissemination.