Musk Fuels Baseless Claims About UK Grooming Gangs, Targeting Gordon Brown
A wave of misinformation surrounding historical child grooming cases in the UK has recently resurfaced and intensified, largely due to amplification by Elon Musk on his social media platform, X (formerly Twitter). The claims center around a purported Home Office memo from 2008, allegedly instructing police to ignore grooming cases because victims had made an "informed choice" about their sexual behavior. These accusations have been directed at former Prime Minister Gordon Brown, with Musk suggesting Brown was complicit in covering up these crimes. However, a BBC Verify investigation has debunked the existence of such a memo, exposing the claims as entirely fabricated.
The misinformation campaign hinges on a 2018 BBC radio interview with Nazir Afzal, then Chief Crown Prosecutor for North-West England. Afzal claimed a Home Office circular advised police against intervening in grooming cases due to victims’ supposed "informed choice." This statement has since been misinterpreted and widely shared online. Afzal himself has now admitted to BBC Verify that he never saw the alleged circular and was paraphrasing what he believed some police officers’ interpretations of existing guidelines to be. He pointed to a 2008 Home Office circular concerning police powers under the Children’s Act, which contains no mention of "informed choice" and is unrelated to child grooming.
BBC Verify’s comprehensive research, including scrutiny of Home Office archives and the National Archives, has found no evidence to support the existence of the purported memo. All official Home Office circulars and memos from 2008 are publicly available, and none contain the language or instructions described in the online accusations. Searches for related phrases, like "lifestyle choice", also yielded no results. Numerous Freedom of Information requests have similarly failed to uncover any such document.
The misinformation spread rapidly after Musk shared posts echoing the baseless allegations. One post, viewed over 25 million times, directly implicated Gordon Brown in a cover-up, accusing him of "selling those little girls for votes." Others amplified the claims, often referencing Afzal’s 2018 statement as evidence. The Home Office has emphatically denied ever issuing such guidance, stating unequivocally that there is "no truth in the existence of a Home Office circular telling police forces that grooming gangs should not be prosecuted." Gordon Brown has called the allegations “a complete fabrication,” emphasizing that he had no involvement in issuing any such circular.
While the circulated memo is confirmed to be fictitious, the underlying issue of child sexual exploitation and the institutional responses to it remain critical. Professor Alexis Jay, who led the independent inquiry into child sexual abuse, highlighted the systemic failures in protecting victims and investigating these crimes. The inquiry revealed repeated instances of ignored allegations, victim-blaming, and institutions prioritizing their reputations over child safety. The current wave of misinformation, regardless of its factual inaccuracy, underscores the importance of continued scrutiny and accountability in addressing these complex issues.
The propagation of these baseless accusations, fueled by social media amplification, highlights the dangers of misinformation and its potential to damage reputations and distract from genuine concerns. While the claims targeting Gordon Brown have been thoroughly debunked, the incident serves as a stark reminder of the need for critical evaluation of online information and the responsibility of high-profile figures to avoid disseminating unsubstantiated allegations. The incident also brings to the fore the need for continued investigation and improvement of institutional responses to child sexual abuse, ensuring that victims receive proper support and justice.
