Misinformation Mars Maharashtra Elections: Old Delhi Protest Footage Falsely Linked to EVM Concerns
The aftermath of the Maharashtra state assembly elections has been marred by a wave of misinformation, with a video circulating on social media falsely claiming to depict widespread protests against electronic voting machines (EVMs) in the wake of the BJP-led alliance’s landslide victory. The video, shared across platforms like Facebook and X (formerly Twitter), purports to show crowds taking to the streets across Maharashtra to voice their concerns over alleged EVM tampering. However, a thorough fact-check reveals that the footage is not from Maharashtra and predates the recent elections by several months. The video, in reality, documents an anti-EVM demonstration held in Delhi’s Jantar Mantar in January 2024, months before the Maharashtra polls took place.
The misleading social media posts capitalized on the pre-existing atmosphere of skepticism surrounding EVMs, which resurfaced after opposition leaders leveled accusations of irregularities following the BJP’s resounding win. These allegations fueled genuine protests within Maharashtra, with citizens expressing their apprehension about the integrity of the electoral process. The Election Commission of India responded to the concerns by promising a transparent review of the opposition’s claims, aiming to address the mounting public distrust. However, the emergence of the out-of-context video further muddied the waters, adding another layer of complexity to the ongoing debate surrounding the use of EVMs in Indian elections.
The false narrative surrounding the video was amplified by captions and accompanying text that explicitly linked the footage to the Maharashtra elections. One Hindi-language Facebook post asserted that a "spark to remove EVM" had ignited a movement in Maharashtra, with people protesting the Election Commission in numerous villages. This inflammatory language, combined with the visually compelling footage of a large protest, effectively misled users into believing that widespread public dissent against EVMs had erupted in Maharashtra following the election results. The misrepresentation of the video exploited the heightened political sensitivities and contributed to the spread of misinformation regarding the electoral process.
The true origin of the video was uncovered through a combination of reverse image searches and keyword analysis. The distinctive Hindi chants heard in the video led researchers to a YouTube video posted by the Indian newspaper O Heraldo in January 2024. This video clearly identified the location of the protest as Jantar Mantar in Delhi and described it as part of a nationwide movement advocating for the ban of EVMs. Further corroboration came from news reports and images published by other Indian media outlets, confirming that the protest took place in Delhi following allegations of EVM tampering and misuse by the ruling BJP ahead of the Lok Sabha elections.
A detailed comparison of the viral video with the O Heraldo footage reveals undeniable similarities, including identical signage specific to Jantar Mantar. The signboards visible in both videos provide irrefutable visual evidence that the protest depicted took place in Delhi, not Maharashtra. This conclusive visual proof, combined with the corroborating news reports and the established timeline of the January protest, definitively debunks the claim that the video represents post-election protests in Maharashtra.
The incident underscores the challenges posed by the rapid spread of misinformation in the digital age, particularly in a politically charged environment. The false narrative surrounding the video not only misrepresented the public sentiment in Maharashtra but also undermined genuine concerns regarding electoral transparency. The incident serves as a stark reminder of the importance of verifying information from multiple credible sources before accepting and sharing it online. The Election Commission of India has affirmed its commitment to addressing the concerns raised regarding EVMs and ensuring the integrity of the electoral process. However, the propagation of false information like this video only serves to complicate matters and erode public trust. As India moves forward, fostering media literacy and critical thinking becomes paramount to combatting the spread of disinformation and safeguarding the democratic process.
