Trump’s False Claim About Harris Rally Crowd Debunked by Evidence
Former President Donald Trump recently made a false claim on his Truth Social platform, alleging that a large crowd depicted in a photo from Vice President Kamala Harris’s rally in Detroit, Michigan, was non-existent and that the image itself was AI-generated. This assertion has been thoroughly debunked by multiple sources of visual evidence, including photographs and videos from various media outlets, attendees, and the Harris campaign itself.
The image in question, which shows a substantial crowd gathered to hear Harris speak, was initially shared on X (formerly Twitter) by a Harris campaign staffer. Trump seized upon this image to falsely claim the crowd was fabricated. However, numerous other images and videos from the event, including footage from reputable news organizations like NBC News and PBS, clearly show a large crowd present at the rally. A BBC presenter who attended the event also confirmed the significant size of the crowd, noting that it stretched onto the airfield.
Further solidifying the veracity of the crowd’s presence, Getty Images captured numerous photos showcasing the large gathering at the Detroit rally. These images corroborate the accounts from other sources, leaving no doubt about the substantial number of attendees. The Harris campaign provided the BBC with what they claim is the original photograph, taken by a campaign staff member on an iPhone. Metadata analysis of this image by the BBC confirmed its authenticity and timestamp, aligning with the timing of the rally.
Addressing the online speculation surrounding the photo, the Harris campaign confirmed the image’s authenticity and denied any AI manipulation. They stated that the photo was taken by their staff and has not been altered in any way. They also provided additional images from the same vantage point, taken moments before the disputed photo, which clearly show the same crowd, albeit partially obscured by shadows. This suggests that the brighter appearance of the contested image may be due to adjustments made to compensate for the shadowing.
Furthermore, some online commentators pointed to perceived anomalies in the picture as "proof" of AI manipulation. These included the lack of a crowd reflection on the plane’s fuselage and the absence of an identification number on the tail of Air Force Two. However, these observations are easily explained. Other photos from the event show the same area of the plane’s reflection without a visible crowd. This is likely due to the angle of reflection capturing a clear area of tarmac in front of the plane. The absence of the tail number has also been observed in other recent photos and videos of Air Force Two, suggesting it may have been temporarily removed.
Finally, expert analysis further dispels the AI manipulation theory. Professor Hany Farid, a specialist in image analysis at UC Berkeley, examined the photograph using software specifically designed to detect AI-generated imagery. His analysis found no evidence of AI generation or digital alteration, further corroborating the authenticity of the image and debunking Trump’s false claims. The convergence of eyewitness accounts, photographic evidence, metadata analysis, and expert assessment unequivocally confirms the presence of a substantial crowd at Vice President Harris’s Detroit rally and exposes the unsubstantiated nature of Trump’s allegations.
