Tragic Death of Former IPP Prisoner Highlights Systemic Failures
Haydar Jefferies, a 50-year-old former publican, tragically took his own life in HMP Coldingley, Surrey, in March 2023. His death, following a year of deteriorating mental health within the prison walls, has brought the enduring legacy of the now-abolished Imprisonment for Public Protection (IPP) sentences into sharp focus. Jefferies’ case underscores the devastating impact of these indefinite sentences, even after release, and exposes serious failings within the prison system.
Jefferies was initially imprisoned in 2006 under an IPP sentence for assault, serving six years before his release in 2012. The IPP sentence, introduced in 2005, allowed for indefinite detention beyond the minimum tariff, leaving prisoners in a state of perpetual uncertainty. While abolished in 2012, its effects continue to haunt thousands who remain subject to its terms, including the possibility of recall to prison for minor infractions. Jefferies lived for nine years under this shadow, constantly fearful of being returned to prison. Despite this, he rebuilt his life, transforming his Oxfordshire pub into a community hub and becoming a respected figure in his local area.
However, tragedy struck in 2022. Following the sudden death of his husband, a false allegation led to Jefferies’ recall to prison. Despite the police dropping the investigation within months, the IPP sentence meant he remained incarcerated, awaiting a parole hearing. The delay, compounded by the postponement of his hearing due to a panel member’s illness, contributed to his rapidly declining mental state. He developed severe depression and psychosis, experiencing delusions and fearing for his life.
An inquest held in Woking Coroner’s Court in June 2023 delivered a damning verdict. The jury found that gross failures by prison staff to provide basic medical attention amounted to neglect, and that his IPP status and parole hearing delays significantly contributed to his psychosis. Despite repeated calls from his family to the prison highlighting his deteriorating mental health, no action was taken. A referral to the mental health team was made too late, just a day before he attempted suicide.
Jefferies’ family is now demanding urgent changes to the system, calling for an end to the inhumane treatment of IPP prisoners. They describe the prison system as treating inmates like “cattle” and emphasize the urgent need for improved mental health support and due process within prisons. They believe the IPP system, with its indefinite nature and potential for recall, created a climate of fear and hopelessness that ultimately contributed to Haydar’s death. They have urged the government to address the ongoing impact of these sentences on those still trapped within the system.
The case has exposed critical flaws in the prison system’s handling of vulnerable inmates and the devastating consequences of the IPP sentence. Haydar’s story stands as a stark reminder of the human cost of these policies and the pressing need for reform. The inquest findings have raised serious questions about the adequacy of mental health care within prisons and the lack of responsiveness to concerns raised by families. It highlights the need for greater accountability and improved communication between prison staff and families to prevent future tragedies.
The government has recently reduced the IPP licence period from ten years to three, but this change came too late for Haydar. His family’s fight for justice continues, hoping that his death will serve as a catalyst for meaningful change and prevent other families from enduring the same heartbreak. They seek not only accountability for the failings that led to Haydar’s death, but also systemic reform to ensure that the legacy of the IPP sentence does not claim any more lives. Their plea echoes the concerns of human rights organizations and legal experts who have long criticized the devastating and long-lasting impact of these sentences.
