Social Media Platforms Grapple with Disinformation and Harmful Content During 2024 Pakistani General Elections
The 2024 general elections in Pakistan witnessed a surge in disinformation and harmful content across major social media platforms, raising concerns about the efficacy of content moderation policies and their impact on democratic processes. A report by the Digital Rights Foundation (DRF) titled "Platforms At The Polls: Disinformation, Political Ads & Accountability During The 2024 Pakistan General Elections" highlighted the rampant spread of misleading information, particularly targeting female politicians and journalists. The report focused on platforms like TikTok, Facebook/Instagram, YouTube, and X (formerly Twitter), revealing inconsistencies in their content moderation practices compared to regions in the Global North.
The DRF’s analysis of 225 social media posts between November 2023 and March 2024 exposed the extent of the problem. A significant portion, 163 posts, fell under the category of gendered disinformation, targeting women in the public sphere with deepfakes and technology-facilitated gender-based violence (TFGBV). The remaining posts encompassed broader disinformation, misinformation, fake news, generative AI content, and hate speech. The Pakistan Muslim League-N (PML-N) bore the brunt of these attacks, with 76 posts primarily targeting Maryam Nawaz. The Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) faced 61 such posts, while the Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) had 19. Journalists covering the elections were also subject to online abuse, including gendered insults, trolling campaigns, and even threats of physical assault (47 posts). Ethnic, indigenous, and transgender communities were also targeted in 13 posts.
Despite comprehensive policies outlined by these platforms regarding electoral information integrity, their practical implementation in Pakistan and other South Asian countries proved inadequate. This disparity between stated policies and actual enforcement raises serious concerns about the platforms’ commitment to curbing harmful content, especially during sensitive periods like elections. The lack of transparency regarding political advertising expenditure further complicated the issue. While Meta (Facebook and Instagram) disclosed that political parties spent a combined Rs54 million (approximately $190,000) on campaign ads, other platforms offered no such insights.
The PTI emerged as the largest spender on Facebook and Instagram, allocating Rs25 million for political ads, followed by the Istehkam-e-Pakistan Party (IPP) with Rs13 million, Jamaat-e-Islami (JI) with Rs6 million, the PPP with Rs5 million, and the PML-N with Rs0.79 million. This lack of transparency from platforms other than Meta prevents a complete understanding of the financial influence wielded through social media during the elections. The opacity surrounding political ad spending raises questions about potential manipulation and undue influence on public opinion.
Nighat Dad, Executive Director of DRF, emphasized the crucial role of social media platforms in upholding electoral integrity and democratic norms. She pointed out the severe offline consequences that can arise from the unchecked spread of disinformation, particularly when platforms fail to address election-related manipulation effectively and timely. The 2024 Pakistani elections serve as a stark reminder of the challenges posed by online disinformation and the urgent need for improved content moderation practices.
The DRF report underscores the need for social media companies to prioritize information integrity and implement consistent election-related content moderation policies globally, particularly in regions like South Asia. The prevalence of gendered disinformation and the targeting of vulnerable communities necessitates a more proactive approach from these platforms to safeguard democratic processes and protect individuals from online harm. The lack of transparency in political ad spending further underscores the need for greater accountability from social media companies. Addressing these issues is essential to ensure fair and democratic elections in the digital age.
