Turkish Journalist Sentenced for Earthquake Reporting, Highlighting Press Freedom Concerns
Istanbul, Turkey – A Turkish court’s recent sentencing of journalist Yüsra Batıhan has reignited concerns about press freedom in the country, particularly in the aftermath of the devastating February 2023 earthquakes. Batıhan received a 10-month suspended sentence for allegedly spreading disinformation about the disaster, a charge stemming from her reporting for the pro-Kurdish Mezopotamya news agency. Her lawyer has announced plans to appeal the verdict. The case highlights the precarious environment faced by journalists in Turkey, where accusations of disseminating misleading information have been increasingly used to stifle critical reporting.
The earthquakes, measuring magnitudes 7.8 and 7.5, struck southeastern Turkey on February 6, 2023, leaving a trail of destruction and claiming the lives of over 53,000 people. Millions were left homeless. While stories of miraculous rescues emerged, they often overshadowed the harsh realities on the ground and the systemic failures that contributed to the scale of the tragedy. In the wake of the disaster, reporting on the government’s response became a sensitive issue, with allegations of censorship and suppression of information surfacing.
Batıhan’s reports, which detailed the undocumented burial of earthquake victims and the alleged seizure of aid supplies by authorities, appear to have fallen into this sensitive territory. She was convicted under Article 217 of the Turkish Penal Code, a provision often used to target journalists and critics. The Media and Law Studies Association (MLSA) has documented numerous instances of censorship and legal action against journalists reporting on the earthquake aftermath. These instances include the temporary shutdown of Twitter, the detention and arrest of journalists, and investigations into at least 18 journalists for "disseminating misleading information."
The government’s actions in the post-earthquake period reflect a broader pattern of media control in Turkey. Critics contend that since a failed coup attempt in 2016, the government has systematically tightened its grip on the press, shutting down media outlets and imprisoning journalists under the guise of fighting the coup. The chilling effect of these actions has created an environment where journalists fear losing their jobs, facing legal harassment, or even imprisonment for critical reporting.
Turkey’s ranking as 158th out of 180 countries in the 2024 World Press Freedom Index, compiled by Reporters Without Borders, further underscores the country’s declining press freedom landscape. The organization has described Turkey as the world’s biggest jailer of journalists, a stark reminder of the risks faced by those who dare to challenge the official narrative. The case of Yüsra Batıhan adds another chapter to this troubling story, raising concerns about the ability of Turkish journalists to freely and independently report on critical issues, particularly those related to government accountability and disaster response.
International press freedom organizations and human rights groups have repeatedly voiced concerns about the erosion of media freedoms in Turkey. They argue that the government’s actions create an atmosphere of fear and self-censorship, hindering the free flow of information and undermining democratic principles. The implications of restricted press freedom extend beyond the media itself, impacting the public’s access to accurate information and limiting the ability of citizens to hold their government accountable. The international community continues to monitor the situation in Turkey closely, advocating for greater protection of journalists and the restoration of press freedom as a fundamental pillar of a democratic society. The outcome of Batıhan’s appeal will be closely watched as a barometer of Turkey’s commitment to these principles.
